First Requirement:
This certification requires that New Building or Building Renovation projects demonstrate a 20% reduction in the embodied carbon of primary materials (structural, foundation, and enclosure elements) and exterior materials (permanently installed site elements) when compared to an equivalent baseline (equivalency based on size, function, and energy performance). For Building Renovation projects, the reuse of on-site primary and exterior materials may be directly counted against the required reduction.
An embodied carbon assessment is required to be performed for the project and to establish a reference baseline, in accordance with ISO 14044. This assessment must consider upfront carbon including construction phase emissions (life cycle stages A1 through A5 as defined by EN 15978). Assessments of embodied carbon need to be completed with an approved tool. ILFI provides a list of approved tools consisting of both WBLCA tools, like Tally, Athena Impact Estimator, and One Click LCA, and also allows for use of Product Data and Embodied Carbon Calculator Tools, like EC3.
ILFI specifically encourages the use of current, product specific, geographically relevant, and third-party-reviewed EPDs, conforming to ISO 14025, whenever possible. ILFI also encourages advocacy for development of product-specific EPDs when data is not available for a project and provides a sample advocacy letter for use.
The project’s baseline should be identical to the initial design except for the claimed material reductions. In particular, ILFI requires that it is similar in project scope and use material and design parameters based on standard industry practices. ILFI also requires that the implemented reduction strategies be organized into one of three categories: material quantity reduction, material alternatives, and product alternatives. Additional information on establishing a project baseline, product baseline, and embodied carbon assessment scope can be found in the Zero Carbon Certification program manual, version 1.1 from ILFI.
As part of the embodied carbon assessment for the project, structural engineers should either directly perform or advise the team on the portion of the assessment related to their scope. Preliminary embodied carbon assessment results and an understanding of materials’ embodied carbon can help determine high carbon impact areas and allow the structural engineer to actively provide solutions to meet the 20% reduction requirement.
Early in the design phase, the design team should agree on which consultant should include the various components of the embodied carbon assessment in their scope, including development of the baseline and final calculations. The structural engineer will also need to understand how the required reductions will be achieved, and include requirements in their drawings and specifications as needed, or allow time for design alternative investigations or design optimization. By measuring and utilizing reduction strategies, structural engineers can reduce the building’s embodied carbon footprint to the greatest extent possible.
Second Requirement:
Embodied carbon must be considered for interior materials if they are within the project scope. Interior products must be selected with a lower than industry average carbon footprint for categories which embodied carbon data is readily available.
Third Requirement:
Projects must account for and offset all embodied carbon emissions associated with the project. This can be achieved by utilizing carbon-sequestering materials and/or a one-time carbon offset purchase through an ILFI approved carbon offset provider.
The Zero Carbon Certification program manual provides scope clarifications for the embodied carbon assessment including the following:
- As noted above, biogenic carbon may be included in the analysis, provided the Living Building Challenge’s strict sustainable sourcing requirements are met. Project teams are encouraged to report structural embodied carbon intensity both with and without biogenic carbon to illustrate its impact on the results. Projects electing to include biogenic carbon must coordinate applicable sourcing and documentation requirements early in design and incorporate them into the project specifications.
- Offsets must consider primary material assemblies, interior material assemblies and exterior material assemblies.
- Building renovation projects must consider embodied carbon associated with the refurbishment, transport, and installation of salvaged or reused materials (A3-A5) and the embodied carbon of any new materials. Existing materials are not considered relative to carbon offsets.
Fourth Requirement:
Projects must be designed to be within a maximum embodied carbon threshold of 350 kgCO2e/m2 for A1-A5 scope considering primary material assemblies, interior material assemblies, and exterior material assemblies. Based on SE 2050 data analysis reports, this threshold is approximately the 85th percentile for structural systems alone, highlighting the importance of reducing structural embodied carbon to accommodate contributions from other assemblies.
For some projects this requirement may result in additional effort for embodied carbon reductions. Pathways are provided to provide a narrative documenting reduction efforts and specific constraints that prevent the threshold from being attainable if applicable.